Yesterday, we went to the ancient ruins, Tel Gezer, for a tiyul. Tel Gezer is located on the “Derech Hayam” or road of the sea, due to its central location in the Fertile Crescent. Like in the game ‘Risk’, the Middle East is a perfect place to trade as it is a pathway to three continents. Of the 5 geographical areas in Israel, Gezer is strategically located next to the coastal plain, in the foothills. Even though the city itself is not large, its location makes it incredibly important to trade around the world.
My impressions of the Canaanite people who lived in this area are extremely mixed. Intelligently, the Canaanites made the walls surrounding the city over 30 meters thick. These casemate walls made it virtually impossible for anyone to penetrate the village. Secondly, even without the use of modern power tools, they were able to tap into the water table by manually digging over 40 meters through bedrock. While there is no doubt these people were nifty (not to use a play on words), some may say they were also inhumane. The Canaanites had many slaves working inside the walls of the city. Also, many of the “lesser” beings of the town, such as prostitutes, were given homes inside of the defensive wall where the rooms could be more easily destroyed.
In the Torah portion Lekh Lekha, God tells Avram to go to the land that he will show him, all in exchange for a brit, or covenant. Avram (who later becomes Avraham) packs his bags and travels place to place looking for this land and a place to settle. Along this journey, Avraham looks for the five D’s that stand for what you need for a well-established civilization. The five D’s are Drink, Diet, Defense, Deals and Deity. In a place such as Gezer, Avraham would find Drink, a big well. He also would find lots of food (Diet), a great security wall (Defense) and lots of opportunity for trade outside of the city entrance (Deals). However, Avraham failed to find Deity. In the city, Avraham found a series of altars where sacrifices were held. Unfortunately for Avraham, these people were polytheistic. Avraham, though, would only pray to one god.
In Tel Gezer, archaeologists found many artifacts that gave historicity to the site. In the area, archaeologists found a large shard with writing on it, an ostracon, with a calendar on it. This calendar showed all of the harvest festivals which were extremely important to the Jews. On the same tablet, a few stray marks can be seen indicating that perhaps a child was practicing writing. This may show that this ancient Jewish civilization valued education (the calendar was anachronistic, as it was found from the time of King Solomon, about 1,000 years after the Canaanites). Archaeologists also found an Arab village nearby called Charab Jazal, which sounds very similar to Gezer. Lastly, as mentioned earlier, archaeologists found huge idols where people made sacrifices to the gods. This is extremely similar to the story in the Tanakh when God tells Abraham to sacrifice his son, Isaac. This connection leads me and others to believe that it may have been a tradition to sacrifice children. In conclusion, how do you think that the attempted sacrifice of Isaac affected the relationship between Avraham and his son? Also, was this attempted sacrifice justified because god sent Avraham to do it?

As a young person, Isaac was likely seriously affected by the event of his near sacrifice, made even more damaging seeing as it broke the trust between himself and someone who he likely idolized - his father. We wouldn't know if Isaac ever came to agree with his father's actions over the course of his life, but it probably induced detrimental feelings of betrayal at the time, and maybe even doubt regarding his father's love to him. Personally, I don't believe Avraham's actions should be justified by saying God told him to. A God shouldn't be someone/something that causes you to do harm onto another person for benefit.
ReplyDeleteI would imagine Isaac would be incredibly traumatized by his father's attempt on his life. Father figures are a repeated pattern we see in Jewish history, with many stories emphasizing father-son bonds and father-son traditions. From this we can assume father and son relationships where very prevalent and important in the time of Isaac and Jacob. So to have Isaacs connection with his father to be so broken and upset at such an early age would be very difficult on Isaac. This may be one of the reasons Isaac never became a bigger prophet like his father or his son became. Though it was god's commandment, Avraham never should have attempted to sacrifice his own son. He clearly understood what he was doing was wrong because he did not tell Isaac what his intention was going to be on top of the mountain, as they first began their journey. Abraham should have put more value in his sons life, and at least tried to refuse to kill his own son, when god initially commanded him to do so.
ReplyDeleteI think that Isaac would have a lot of issues with potential future relationships because of the trauma he went through by his father almost sacrificing him. Although God told Avraham to sacrifice Isaac, I don't think it was justified how he made the decision so easily. It's his own son, and he acted as if he didn't even matter. Avraham also lied to Isaac about where they were going when he almost sacrificed him, creating trust issues for Isaac with his father, and probably others as well. I would imagine that Isaac also felt insecure, and that his father did not love him.
ReplyDeleteI believe Abraham's attempted sacrifice of his own son Isaac most likely would have hindered a strong relationship from developing. If it were my own father who were to try to sacrifice me, I definitely would have been extremely resentful, and probably even hateful. There would have been nothing he could have said or done to make me forgive him. In any father-child relationship, it is safe to assume that some level of resentment would be present. In my opinion, the sacrifice is not justified just because God told Abraham to. Earlier in Genesis, Abraham questions God's actions and expresses that he wants to save the innocent people. Likewise, Abraham should not be afraid to refer to his own morals and spare his own son.
ReplyDeleteI think the attempted sacrifice permanently damaged the relationship between Abraham and Isaac. Abraham's actions showed Isaac that Abraham valued his relationship with God over his relationship with his own son. After the attempted sacrifice, Abraham and Isaac don't really interact with each other directly, which shows that their relationship was estranged for the rest of Abraham's life. I think the sacrifice was completely unjustified. Firstly, God made a brit with Abraham promising that he would have many descendants, so sacrificing Isaac makes no sense. In addition, God is supposed to be merciful and calling upon a father to kill his beloved son is really horrific.
ReplyDeleteAs a young child who repsected and trusted his father, Isaac must have been very traumatized when he witnessed his own father try to take the life of his son. Isaac would have had to live with knowing that his father would have actually gone through with this and accept the fact that Abraham chose God (an unknown and unexplored force) over the life of his own child. I don't think that this attempt at Isaac's life was justified even if God told Abraham to do it. The fear of God should never destroy the bond between family.
ReplyDeleteIt is my belief that isaac's relationship with his father was negatively impacted by this experience. A child would 100% be traumatized if their parent attempted to sacrifice them to god. As one of my classmates pointed out when we were sitting on one of the viewing points, the Torah never states that Isaac ascended down the mountain with his father. This may show how he went into a great a chick and could not bring himself to be with his family. In terms of a modern lens I really don't think human sacrifice is justified, but it seems to have been a standard practice at the time and this is why Abraham does so without even questioning gods will.
ReplyDeleteI believe the attempted sacrifice completely ruined the father son relationship. Even if God asked avraham to sacrifice his favorite son, it still is not justified because it would be the murder of an innocent. One of our commandments is do not murder, and sacrificing Isaac for God would be considered murder, and against the commandments. If my own father attempted to sacrifice me, I would never be able to forgive him. Also, Avraham never even questioned God's motives. If Avraham was asked to sacrifice his whole family would be do it without question as well?
ReplyDeleteI believe the attempted sacrifice completely destroyed the relationship between Isaac and Avraham. If Isaac was Avrahams favorite son, then they must of had a good relationship, with lots of trust between them. Having your father almost kill you when you trust him so must would be traumatizing, and would destroy any relationship no matter how close the two people are. I do not believe that the sacrifice is justified because it was sent from god. I believe this because the love between family members should come before any religion, no matter how religious you are.
ReplyDeleteMadison Holt-
ReplyDeleteDue to Avrahams actions, his relationship with his son, Isaac, will be completely ruined. Isaac had a lot of trust and respect in his father especially since he knew he was his favored son. However, he broke not only his trust but his respect as well in a way that could not be repaired by attempting to murder him. Isaac will never be able to trust his father the same, for he will always remember the day when his father was so willing to take his life. I do not believe Abraham's actions were justified because at some point your own values, especially relating to family, should rise above religion. No one’s life should be at risk because of religion.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteIsaac without a doubt was very traumatized by this event. Having your father place a knife against you is an image that will stay with you for the rest of your life. The relationship between Isaac and Abraham could never be the same after this. Isaac's opinion of his father will drastically change because he now understands his father's true character. Isaac now knows that his father values his relationship with God more that his relationship with his son. Although God sent Abraham to perform this act, I ultimately do not consider this act to be just because a father should NEVER commit such a thing to his own child. This act represents everything that a father should not be. A father is supposed to nurture his son and this is exactly the opposite of that. Even though this story is one of the most prominent ones in the Torah, I do not consider it to be a just act in the slightest.
DeleteThe attempted sacrifice of Isaac affected the relationship between Avraham and his son in a very traumatizing way. Isaac, in complete disbelief from his fathers' actions, holding a knife above his chest and knowing that his father is willing to sacrifice anything that surrounds him will for God. After this event, there is no such thing as a "normal" relationship between Isaac and his father. In addition, Isaac now understands that his father values his relationship with God more than his own son. Isaac had a lot of trust and respect to his father but to what extent will his father go? Although God had sent Avraham to sacrifice his son Isaac, I do not think that Avraham attempt sacrifice was justified because there must be a line that separates religion and family. Avraham should've known that family should have been an exemption and there should've denied God's request of the sacrifice. Overlooking Avraham decisions, I believe that his loyalty to God and the willingness of doing what God asks made him make the decision.
ReplyDeleteI think the attempted sacrifice of Isaac shook Isaac for the rest of his life. Not much is mentioned after this of Isaac so it is reasonable to assume his relationship with his father was strained. The question of it was justified is a complicated one; Abraham was living in a world where the will of God was the ultimate good. If morals are purely based on God and he commanded Abraham to sacrifice his son, then it was justified.
ReplyDeleteIsaac was scarred for life because his own father tried to sacrifice him like that's super scary. They defenitly will never have the same relationship anymore. I think it's justified because Abraham was following gods orders which means it's okay in my opinion because whatever God commands you are supposed to follow.
ReplyDelete