Wednesday, May 3, 2017

Yom Hazikaron/Yom Hatzmaut

As a kehillah of NFTY Heller High, we had the opportunity of experiencing the dramatic switch between the memorial day of Yom HaZikaron and the independence day of Yom Hatzmaut
We began Yom Hazikaron with the rest of Israel on Friday night by attending a ceremony at the Kotel. It was a new environment for most of us. All of those attending stood together to listen to the words of President Rivlin as well as the other leaders of the ceremony. It began with the siren that was sounded all across the nation. I found it striking that we were able to hear this symbolic siren standing right in front of the Western Wall, surrounded by so many Israelis. I particularly liked how we all stood together not separated by gender, regardless of stream of Judaism. Something that stood out to me was the first torch lit at the ceremony. This was done by Rivlin along with two sons and a widow who lost her husband a few years ago as he was serving in the IDF. I found it heartwarming that the gratitude was shown to this mourning family as a sign of immense respect and dedication. Another part of the ceremony that stood out to me was everybody joining together in prayer, like the Mourners’ Kaddish. No matter what stream of Judaism you identify with, each person knew how much this prayer meant and understood the appreciation they owed to soldiers that had given their lives for Israel. This is similar with the Hatikva, as there was a large sense of unification amongst the crowd and ceremony participants.

                            Ceremony at the Kotel

The following day we continued to observe Yom HaZikaron. As a NFTY kehillah, we attended the ceremony for the 
memorial day as a part of Kibbutz Tzuba. It was interesting to observe how the community, that sometimes we forget lives amongst us, comes together to mourn over the losses of those who come from here, regardless of if they even knew them. Different members of the Kibbutz rose to speak and share words and songs of memory and appreciation. Specifically, the Kibbutz mourned two men who had given their lives fighting for Israel. 
The very same night after observing memorial day, we traveled to Ben Yehuda Street in order to begin Yom Hatzmaut. The switch from mourning to celebration was very intense. I had never personally experienced an instance in which a community went from such sadness to such vibrant cheer. The area was filled with loud music, dancing, food, etc. It was 
definitely some of the most fun a lot of us had had so far during our semester.


Yesterday, for Yom Hatzmaut, we celebrated by going to Palmachim Beach. It was an extremely relaxing day, where we enjoyed much free time. We shared our joy in the privilege of having Israel as a place we can call home. Many of us swam in the sea, tanned (or burned), played sports, and just hung out with friends. I can definitely say that I personally had much time to reflect and become thankful for the establishment of this state, as it has given me much opportunity and security. 

So, what do you think of the change from the memorial day to the independence day? Is it too dramatic? Is it better in theory or in practice? 

9 comments:

  1. I really enjoyed the dramatic difference between the two days. Though Yom HaZikaron was tragic, it only made Yom HaTzmaut feel more special. It was also a nice relief from the sadness we had been thinking of the day before. Though I could also see how this happy holiday would overshadow the day of memorial, and make it seem less significant than it is. But the fun activities and beach day definitely took my mind off the sadness we had faced before, and gave me a good transition back into my everyday life.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think that although the difference certainly is dramatic, the joyous change to Yom HaTzmaut reminded everyone that the mourning of death must be coupled with a celebration of life. In the end, those who fought for Israel and perished should not be remembered as simply soldiers who died, we should remember the wonderful moments and importance of their lives as well as commemorate their ultimate sacrifice so that we might enjoy a better life. I don't believe that a happier holiday ignores a time to mourn, but lifts spirits and carries an easier transition to the next day.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think that the change from memorial day to independence day is very dramatic. For memorial day, everyone is in a very somber mood all day. They are very sad because most people have lost someone in the IDF. It is crazy how at night it transitions to independence day. At that time, it is absolutely crazy how festive and upbeat people are. I think that it was very good in practice because it seems like most people were able to get over their somber moods fairly quickly.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I don't think the change between the two days is too dramatic. In order to move out of the intense sadness of Yom Hazikaron, you need an intensely happy day like Yom Hatzmaut. That being said, if someone really close to me died, I think I would feel really offended by the way Israeli society seems to collectively forget and "get over" Yom Hazikaron.

    ReplyDelete
  6. A big part of mourning in Judaism is the idea of celebrating someone's life and accomplishments instead of dwelling on the loss of a life. I think that because of this, it's important to mourn those who were lost in war but then celebrate and enormous and important success that these soldiers had. The acquisition of a Jewish state is what soldiers have fought for for years and will continue to fight for. Because of this, it's important to then celebrate Independence day to show that we are eternally grateful for the sacrifices that soldiers have made.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I like the change between the two days, especially the order of the days. Yom Hazikaron should be put first because it reminds people all the sacrifices that people fought for to have freedom in the Jewish State. Even to this day, young Israeli soldiers die for freedom. I found this day extremely depressing so I really enjoyed that after 24 hours, you celebrate the Jewish States independence. It reminds people outcome through all the sacrifices and also it ends on a happy note.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I think that the dramatic change between memorial day and independence day is really important and shows a lot about the country. It's good to have one day where we mourn the death of the soldiers, but then go into celebrating the amazing country that we now have because of them.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Personally, I particularly like the drastic change between these two days. Yom Hazikaron gives Israelis the chance to take a moment to look on the lives of the soldiers that have fallen. I like how Independence day comes right after because it gives Yom Hazikaron special meaning. It shows that the fallen soldiers lives have given us the free state we have today.

    ReplyDelete